Dear David, Cc AuthZ-land, ;o) I went through the first of the specs you've been putting together at OGF and have comments/typos/tweaks etc. It is attached... I will try to find time to go through the others in the not too distant future. On the suggestion that I fill in your AuthZ template on the Profiles and how I am testing them, I will do this when I know for sure what these specs are proposing/doing. As usual with most of these things, I am happy to test out the implementations across a variety of e-Science projects we are involved here at NeSC. This includes testing Valerio's implementations when they are ready. Hope this helps.. Cheers, Rich PS For those on the list that did not attend OGF21 in Seattle, it was recognised that lack of email traffic was not a good sign for this group (and other groups for that matter at OGF). If folk think this authZ is important, then the community must engage. (David did not bribe me to say this... ;o)) -- Professor Richard O. Sinnott Technical Director National e-Science Centre University of Glasgow, Glasgow G12 8QQ Tel: +44-(0)141-330-8606 Fax: -8625 Mob: 0795-2376627 Email: r.sinnott@nesc.gla.ac.uk