A number of us have been meeting via concall for the past few weeks, to discuss each of the comments that have been received. We have identified the responses that need to be made, but have not formulated those response yet. May of the comments will require further discussion among the group. Over the next few hours/day, I will be posting the comments to the list. This is primarily for the purpose of getting them into the records for the group, but hopefully will also spur some discussion. The response to comments should be based on building consensus based on what has already been accomplished. This is not a time to request or expect extensive changes to the UR document. Getting the document "approved" is only the first step in setting a "standard". The process is highly iterative, so we ask your support and patience as we try to finish up version 1. We will discuss the open comments in a face-to-face session at GGF17 in Tokyo next week. I will post the meeting information to the mailing list shortly. Thanks for all your help and interest in this project. LM ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Laura F. McGinnis, Project Coordinator Data & Information Resource Services Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center email: lfm@psc.edu 300 South Craig Street, #313 voice: 412-268-5642 Pittsburgh, PA 15213 fax: 412-268-8200 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++