Looks great to me! One minor thingie: SIDL allows actually for default parameters, so instead of list_services (in string service_filter, in string data_filter, in string vo_filter, out array<service_description> services); list_services (in string service_filter, in string data_filter, out array<service_description> services); you could write list_services (in string service_filter, in string data_filter, in string vo_filter = "", out array<service_description> services); That would keep it consistent with the detailed spec, where you list only the long version (and rightly so). I think we agreed at OGF22 that we would not need another call on the mailing list, as we seem to have group agreement since quite some time. So, yes, I think its good to go to the Editor. Thanks!!! :-)) Best, Andre. Quoting [Fisher, SM (Steve)] (Mar 06 2008):
Subject: Emailing: saga_sd.dvi From: "Fisher, SM (Steve)" <S.M.Fisher@rl.ac.uk> To: Andre Merzky <andre@merzky.net> Cc: saga-rg@ggf.org
<<saga_sd.dvi>> Andre,
At last I have made the requested changes to the SD spec. Does anybody object to it going for public comment now?
Steve
-- "We've got too much time to waste to stand around here doing things." - Tigger