I'm on the road this Thursday and unable to call-in.

The internal authz call-out interface discussion has so far yielded 23
email messages in the last couple of days among David, Von and myself
without any clear decisive stated direction yet - please bear with us
while we struggle to find the right PATH.

-Frank.


Hiro Kishimoto wrote:
> Hi all,
>
> The following is a proposed agenda for OGSA-WG telecon on June 29th.
> Thursday from 8:30am - 10:30am  (CDT).
>
> Dial-in numbers for Thursday:
>   Free: +1-888-452-0308
>   Intl/Toll: +1-484-644-0505
>   PIN:  71815
>
> Screen share service will be provided.
>   URL:         http://ogsa.glance.net
>   Session key: 0629
> See more explanation:
> http://www-unix.gridforum.org/mail_archive/ogsa-wg/2004/06/msg00077.html
>
> 1) Early discussion (20 min)
>         Note taker assignment
>         Roll call
>         Telecon minutes approval (June 22 & 29)
>         - https://forge.gridforum.org/sf/go/doc13624?nav=1
>         - https://forge.gridforum.org/sf/go/doc13628?nav=1
>         Action Items status review (see the bottom of this email)
>         July F2F and GGF18 plan update (if any)
>         Agenda bashing
>
> 2) CDDLM & EMS joint discussion (Jun and Hiro, 30 min)
>         Jun and Hiro will send out revised material before the call.
>
> minutes form July 12 call
>>   - Reviewed Hiro's presenation and XML documents.
>>
>>   - Jun pointed out that codebase is used incorrectly. It should be
>>     used in the BLAST declaration not in the PosixApplication.
>>   - Also it is not clear what the meaning of pre-script is.
>>   ACTION: Hiro to talk with Chris Smith and clarify meaning of
>>           pre-script
>>   ACTION: Jun will correct the CDL XML examples written by Hiro.
>>
>>   - What should be the granular unit of components?
>>     - It may be better to define 'filesystem' or 'database' as
>>       separate components since they may be re-usable in other
>>       contexts. For example, they might be usable also by a 3-tier
>>       application component.
>>     - It was agreed that this kind of refinement is needed. But it is
>>       not a showstopper for delivering the top level CDL for the EMS
>>       sequence scenarios.
>>
>>   - For the EMS scenarios the following CDL documents are needed:
>>     - Original CDL from the repository;
>>     - CDL modified by JM before submission to Deployment service
>>       (portal)
>>     - CDL after deployment (can be retrieved by JM to refine the JSDL
>>       document)
>>     [The deltas should be fairly small.]
>>   - Some explanation on what the constructs in the CDL document mean
>>     would also be useful since not everyone will have read the CDDLM
>>     documents.
>>   - Also highlighting what information (if any) is expected to taken
>>     from the JSDL document and used in CDL (and vice versa)
>>     - In the simplest case it is 'hostname' and path to the installed
>>       executable.
>>   - Andreas volunteered to review these CDL documents before the EMS
>>     call to make sure they provide the expected information.
>
> 3) EMS scenarios (Steven and Andreas, 30 min)
>       Andreas will send out revised scenario document before the call
>
>> - EMS team (Steven, Andreas, Donal) to review data staging scenario
>>   (section 5 of https://forge.gridforum.org/sf/go/doc13591?nav=1 )
>>   Bring to people's attention again at the next EMS call.
>>   (postpone until June 29)
>> - Add sequence diagrams to the scenarios: (postpone until June 29)
>>     - Andreas will do the "Install application" scenario (3.1)
>>     - Mike will do the "Install application using ACS" scenario (3.3)
>>     - Other volunteers welcome. (Andreas will ask Donal for the EPS
>>       scenario)
>>     - Andreas has started doing the sequence diagrams in RSM
>>     - Darren volunteered to help out
>>     - Review again at the next EMS call (June 29)
>> - Andreas will merge draft scenarios and sequence diagrams to the
>>   "EMS Architecture Scenarios" document (postpone until June 29)
>
> 4) OGSA authorization call-out proposal review (Frank 20 min)
> >   - Frank is now consulting with people in GGF (David Chadwick, Von
> >     Welch) on whether his approach can be defined within the AuthZ
> >     group. If there is no agreement then he will accept the XACML
> >     group's decision.
>
> 5) Basic Security Profile Public Comments review (Takuya 20 min)
>       Takuya will send out proposed text change before the call
>
> Minutes from June 22nd call
>>   Reviewed public comments and Takuya's proposed replies
>>   1. Add text explaining that the Secure Channel profile is not
>>      required by all ogsa services. The introduction is probably a
>>      good place for this.
>>   2. [Basic-Security-Profile] usage.  The term is defined in the
>>      document. Takuya to check whether such special terms are used
>>      consistently and that they stand out. Refer to the WSRF BP for a
>>      similar example.
>>   3. Ciphersuites: Agreed that it important to list acceptable
>>      ciphers.
>>      - As a first step Takuya will list up available ones (from the
>>        WS-I BSP); select the ones that are in common use; and then
>>        select the ones that are considered sufficiently safe.
>>      - Review the list at the next BSP teleconf
>>   4. Multiple keys in keyinfo field?
>>     - Takuya to talk to Von in order to understand the use case for
>>       multiple keys; and will propose a resolution at the next BSP
>>       teleconf.
>
> 6) Wrap up
>         AOB
>
> <*NEXT CALL*>
> July 3  (Mon): Independence day (no call)
> July 6  (Thu): EMS scenarios (Steven and Andreas)
> July 10 (Mon): Information model (Ellen and Fred)
>                Roadmap 1.1 (Hiro, ChrisJ, and Jem)
>                Security & BSP Public Comments review (Frank and Takuya)
>                CDDLM & EMS (Jun and Hiro)
> July 13 (Thu): F2F prep (Tom and Hiro)
> July 17-20:    F2F meeting in Chicago (ANL)
>
> Telecon schedule on wiki:
> https://forge.gridforum.org/sf/wiki/do/viewPage/projects.ogsa-wg/wiki/TeleconSchedule
>
>
> <*ACTION ITEMS*>
> > From June 26 call
> - Hiro to confirm contact with (ex-)EGA TC
>
> > From June 12 call
> - Jun will correct the CDL XML examples written by Hiro.
>
> > From June 8 call
> - EMS team (Steven, Andreas, Donal) to review data staging scenario
>   (section 5 of https://forge.gridforum.org/sf/go/doc13591?nav=1 )
>   Bring to people's attention again at the next EMS call.
>   (postpone until June 29)
> - Add sequence diagrams to the scenarios: (postpone until June 29)
>     - Andreas will do the "Install application" scenario (3.1)
>     - Mike will do the "Install application using ACS" scenario (3.3)
>     - Other volunteers welcome. (Andreas will ask Donal for the EPS
>       scenario)
>     - Andreas has started doing the sequence diagrams in RSM
>     - Darren volunteered to help out
>     - Review again at the next EMS call (June 29)
> - Andreas will merge draft scenarios and sequence diagrams to the
>   "EMS Architecture Scenarios" document (postpone until June 29)
>
> > From May 22 call
> - Jay will contact Platform (Chris Smith) and Condor (Miron Livny)
>   to get feedback on pros / cons of the two rendering approaches
>   (postpone until June 19)
> - Darren/Andreas will take the Modeling position paper and
>   discuss it within the JSDL-WG as well (postpone until June 19)
>
> > From April 5 F2F meeting
> - Marvin to send e-mail that explains concerns on compliance suite
>   by GGF & EGA.
>
> Deferred
> - Frank to write up and send to the list a one page summary of
>   the authorization call-out proposal.
>   (April 24 call, postpone until June 14)
> - Jay check and find out relatively small funding to Globus
>   to develop document on their security work (April 6 F2F)
> - Hiro to schedule a discussion in the OGSA F2F after the
>   converged specs drafts are released to discuss which sets of
>   specs to use within OGSA.  (April 4 F2F)

-- 
Frank Siebenlist               franks@mcs.anl.gov
The Globus Alliance - Argonne National Laboratory