Ian,
a) As discussed on last nights telecom, we
are going to allocate up to 30 minutes for other presenters. I have already
sent email to the two people who have requested time.
b) The whole point of this working group
IS to fit into the overall architecture. That is how the charter SHOULD read.
The charter is the contract the working group makes with the steering
committee, and limits the scope of the working group.
c) I don’t understand item c, the draft charter document clearly
states
“Focus/Purpose
The OGSA Execution Management Services (EMS) design team has developed
as part of the OGSA V1 document a draft set of
The milestones are particularly ambitious in order to support the
overall OGSA roadmap and timeline. Fortunately there has already been
significant discussion with the OGSA-WG on the overall
Scope
The scope of the proposed working group is on the
definition of services for service instantiation and management, with a
particular focus initially on legacy “job” services. For example,
using the OGSA V1 nomenclature, service containers and jobs.
“
Andrew
From: owner-
Sent: Monday, March 07, 2005 5:39
PM
To: Andrew Grimshaw;
Subject: Re: [ogsa-wg] Proposed
(DRAFT) Agenda for Basic EM BOF
Three comments:
a) It's important to give time for other people to present. E.g., I suspect
Karl Czajkowski will want to present on our behalf. There will likely be
others. People should be able to sign up ahead of the meeting and get a time
allocation.
b) I don't see how we can require a priori that "the output of
the OGSA-BEM will fit into the overall OGSA EMS architecture." I don't
know what that means, and in any case, we need to see what people come up with.
c) It is important to say something in the BOF description as to
what we expect the scope of "basic execution management service" to
be. E.g., "focused on defining Web services interfaces for job submission,
monitoring, and management."
Ian.
At 05:31 PM 3/7/2005 -0500, Andrew Grimshaw wrote:
The objective of the BOF is to form
the OGSA Basic Execution Management Service Working Group (OGSA-BEM). The
output of the OGSA-BEM will fit into the overall OGSA EMS architecture, as
initially described in the OGSA V1 Document. It is expected that the OGSA EMS
architecture will evolve over time and that evolution will eventually need to
be incorporated. Such incorporation may not take place in this working group
depending on whether OGSA-BEM completes before changes are made in the overall
OGSA-EMS.
Proposed
Agenda
Presentation
of GGF IP Rules
Pass around
sign-up sheet
Background
on OGSA
Basic
Execution Management A Focus on Minimal Services
Draft Service Containers description
Charter
discussion
Should charter be extended to include Actors?
Should the charter be extended to include any form of agreements?
Milestones
Scheduling
of calls
Math & Computer Science Div. Dept of
Computer Science
Argonne National Laboratory The
Tel: 630 252
4619
Fax: 630 252 1997
Globus
Alliance, www.globus.org