I agree with your concern – at least to the level that this needs to be discussed and the material, if included, probably modified. I included it in the draft as a place holder for future discussion. I think I also added a tracker on the matter, but it was very late at night and I might have forgotten to.

This is a topic I’d like to propose for discussion at tomorrow’s teleconference call, if possible.

Marvin.

From: ogsa-hpcp-wg-bounces@ogf.org [mailto:ogsa-hpcp-wg-bounces@ogf.org] On Behalf Of Ian Foster
Sent: Monday, September 04, 2006 8:05 PM
To: Mailing List for OGSA-HPCP-WG; Mailing List for OGSA-HPCP-WG; Peter G. Lane
Cc: ogsa-bes-wg@ggf.org; ogsa-hpcp-wg@ggf.org
Subject: Re: [ogsa-hpcp-wg] Revised version of BES draft specification

I'm concerned about the inclusion of the Appendix entitled "Container Model." This looks like useful material that should be published, but I don't believe it belongs in the BES specification.

At 06:30 PM 9/4/2006 -0500, Ian Foster wrote:

I would like to claim the pen.

Ian.

At 02:56 PM 9/2/2006 -0600, Peter G. Lane wrote:

I'm done with my changes for the moment. The sections I was tasked to fill out were mostly done, so it was mostly just polish. I also did a lot of polishing to the operations, especially the schemas and WSDLs. I'd really appreciate it if people could look at this version before I put it up on the BES documents page. I want to make sure everybody's ok with the changes I made. Here is a general overview of what I did:

- Changed all references to GetActivyStatus and GetActivitiesStatus (the document inconsistently had both) to GetActivityStatuses to be both self consistent and consistent with GetActivityDocuments (according to my dictionary, this is the correct plural of "status").
- Added myself to the authors list.
- Fixed some xsd:any element declarations in operation wrapper types.
- Removed "Type" suffix from all instance elements since they are not complexTypes.
- General clean up of the schema to be consistent and more readable.
- Removed all minOccurs="1" and maxOccurs="1" element attributes since these values are the default.
- Fixed the s12:Fault element declarations.
- Removed duplicate LocalResourceManagerType element from BasicResourceAttributesDocumentType (also exists in BESResourceAttributesDocumentType).
- Added fault element to the GetActivityDocuments response type
- Added explicit wsa:Action attributes to all input and output operation elements
- Updated the non-normative message examples

I should note that the section numbers seem quite messed up. Somebody who has a better idea of where things are supposed to fit ought to make sure the numbers are ok. I would have assumed that Word would take care of this automatically, but I guess not.

Peter

Content-Type: application/x-pkcs7-signature; name="smime.p7s"
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="smime.p7s"
Content-Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature

0€      *†H†÷
€0€10  +0€     *†H†÷
‚P0‚¦0‚Ž Ñ0
        *†H†÷
0i10    ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 0UCertificate Authorities10U
DOEGrids CA 10
051111152456Z
061111152456Z0^10       ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,ddoegrids10
UPeople10UPeter G Lane 3642430‚"0
        *†H†÷
‚0‚‚»Ô”„äÓœÎ<¹ÖM ‹Ù3¶é=ŸvU5âHÚñz®w7¼AhˆÂÃCñ;ŒU“d¥°%ólñŒß=hý„ŸÙmE[w"é!My”"c<ž2n‚Ž[dÿÞ¢fo®°5¶an…WAoØÁaé:Yšñbx=ÕÕ4ÝB©‡"L5”@`?ÛÐ©‡Nk2Åû—ü°ÿ·Þžø·Ÿ=D` É¦9æÑ³ùˆo¸ðÝ±Áä1éß¡Ô—F†®r8"[])}QJn>Õuï¯j^¸[Ñ½1¸•Ùç5èfãIÞoÝÎ?~”Ù‹|CUäÅÓº—;ù€Dy£c0a0      `†H†øBà0Uÿð0U#0€ÊŽn¤8]BÔ1ÛÙ
]0U0lane@mcs.anl.gov0
        *†H†÷
‚|Âr
€¹vçÞW29z¾MbÎí³þÐãsaTÝ“rÁx¶ ±<ð<]@Ígzñö#¬ûúÅÜ‘špxÜÝ¯f^b"À”cÖcX‰>¡ÞD"kPíòëSØ?ú¾=æ#Q¼×›æóh›Žé[…½¯´á0{¡i
õšâÀßó¨¾ŠÎ<â    <ü€‚W0ƒPdæ-±Ú-ÐŽâ
’Z}ÖÏŸ*%D6¸=iSpJ|µ0rÀi'LK×uOÌ/l ÆcÖƒFØ*í«ÁÐ`c
äÃ(¯¯â€`“G®{©æÐ>Ý¾_×÷4¯ÕÙ1÷ø ¦¢=ÿ9ÊJæðé¸¾ç0‚¦0‚Ž Ñ0
        *†H†÷
0i10    ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 0UCertificate Authorities10U
DOEGrids CA 10
051111152456Z
061111152456Z0^10       ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,ddoegrids10
UPeople10UPeter G Lane 3642430‚"0
        *†H†÷
‚0‚‚»Ô”„äÓœÎ<¹ÖM ‹Ù3¶é=ŸvU5âHÚñz®w7¼AhˆÂÃCñ;ŒU“d¥°%ólñŒß=hý„ŸÙmE[w"é!My”"c<ž2n‚Ž[dÿÞ¢fo®°5¶an…WAoØÁaé:Yšñbx=ÕÕ4ÝB©‡"L5”@`?ÛÐ©‡Nk2Åû—ü°ÿ·Þžø·Ÿ=D` É¦9æÑ³ùˆo¸ðÝ±Áä1éß¡Ô—F†®r8"[])}QJn>Õuï¯j^¸[Ñ½1¸•Ùç5èfãIÞoÝÎ?~”Ù‹|CUäÅÓº—;ù€Dy£c0a0      `†H†øBà0Uÿð0U#0€ÊŽn¤8]BÔ1ÛÙ
]0U0lane@mcs.anl.gov0
        *†H†÷
‚|Âr
€¹vçÞW29z¾MbÎí³þÐãsaTÝ“rÁx¶ ±<ð<]@Ígzñö#¬ûúÅÜ‘špxÜÝ¯f^b"À”cÖcX‰>¡ÞD"kPíòëSØ?ú¾=æ#Q¼×›æóh›Žé[…½¯´á0{¡i
õšâÀßó¨¾ŠÎ<â    <ü€‚W0ƒPdæ-±Ú-ÐŽâ
’Z}ÖÏŸ*%D6¸=iSpJ|µ0rÀi'LK×uOÌ/l ÆcÖƒFØ*í«ÁÐ`c
äÃ(¯¯â€`“G®{©æÐ>Ý¾_×÷4¯ÕÙ1÷ø ¦¢=ÿ9ÊJæðé¸¾ç0‚ø0‚à 0
        *†H†÷
0u10    ’&‰“ò,dnet10    ’&‰“ò,dES10UESnet1 0UCertificate Authorities10UESnet Root CA 10
021205080000Z
080110080000Z0i10       ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 0UCertificate Authorities10U
DOEGrids CA 10‚"0
        *†H†÷
‚0‚‚´õÖ#a£Û>fµ¸o²šß-jmr¢‚Èq÷¼+.ËÛcâ,-ÿY"×d
n1ËË.kÙÉ—Ê—íºdÌ´ë`ß’™ IÔwÂŒáQ“HWKTo@lÖ²yþúq¥BÍ~!t.7‘«†8ôÜ5ö^Õ6ZÝí\ö·<5y9%šþgì²KœÅ!k´È€ÍÈ—_ú}!Á£Íç|%’wÓÖƒøcC¸v“ŒQ[7šÎrÎoÓ³µ•QýlW7¾‰ÌÅ‡lpk…]-ƒðÖ—ïcNßªæÑ-tö«Û°ÙZ®ƒÑo«<¦¤@ºJ{Mø]Ì{€êROÅÆ„QZ)ùcw¯?K£ž0›0     `†H†øB‡0UÿÆ0UÊŽn¤8]BÔ1ÛÙ
]0U#0€¼]MH/ø5”Y«\‰K>Ñ²:ê0Uÿ0ÿ0%U0DOEGrids-CA-1@doegrids.org0
        *†H†÷
‚*;b™>3p{)5V#ƒ+±¶(=vÎ”53Œ¡¿(B7â xQ{Â¤´`-#”gÝKøj1q.ãë˜8ÓÕ¶ÙðRa5Ô‰‚j½BFš¹ÃãÚ]=Â£3NQëji_gŒkÝE´´ªxýÊ^Í¸¿´þBkêÛÎ¹ñî¥@Çwè¨(v¶c¶‘JÊHÕdj‚Ý1rI¥ÿ¿£°ôÎ¥½ÐÝ u<iû²@x1îÀÑ¼¯†;DÚ‘ê ©Zµk;>Õz[½TÙï<xG…¸-*Õ#Å)eSÇ½º ·±™ûþêß(ôüYy§@éÀGf¢åÿ.#A»1‚N0‚J0o0i10 ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 0UCertificate Authorities10U
DOEGrids CA 1Ñ0 + ‚´0   *†H†÷
        1       *†H†÷
0       *†H†÷
        1
060902205636Z0# *†H†÷
        1<úÍNþR[9+£ì”$2³S0R    *†H†÷
        1E0C0 *†H†÷
0*†H†÷
€0
*†H†÷
@0+0
*†H†÷
(0~     +‚71q0o0i10     ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 0UCertificate Authorities10U
DOEGrids CA 1Ñ0€*†H†÷
        1q o0i10        ’&‰“ò,dorg10    ’&‰“ò,dDOEGrids1 0UCertificate Authorities10U
DOEGrids CA 1Ñ0
        *†H†÷
‚>ÇÏSm°Šdò;±‡Øþ--‘Ü•|+œÃËfï{qFé,±Çz¾   »UÔ®JÛ¢ÇLˆßHöá ôDú+WÉƒ±¹Æ¹öV¬µó”ïý2˜ÓÎ´5ò4§š:¡²‘¸>bUVq ‡ý¼®©ZøÔ—èO|Œö«0‹—
:céAŒ·Ðú%3äj1‘ÍGÍq&ºÞc [ZÏÄ7§.FZY#É×¸’X^¤lNxèSâWÃàêqØÔäÐç€Ü*™aš€Ó’€êî/n3[m-Sí1p‡7-å„¢:<ŒüÎqµÅ9Ïž…
xFù<Èïâ;^¿t|G.¦Þƒÿ|0ˆ_6
--
ogsa-hpcp-wg mailing list
ogsa-hpcp-wg@ogf.org
http://www.ogf.org/mailman/listinfo/ogsa-hpcp-wg

_______________________________________________________________
Ian Foster -- Weblog: http://ianfoster.typepad.com
Computation Institute: www.ci.uchicago.edu & www.ci.anl.gov
Argonne: MCS/221, 9700 S. Cass Ave, Argonne, IL 60439
Chicago: Rm 405, 5640 S. Ellis Ave, Chicago, IL 60637
Tel: +1 630 252 4619 --- Globus Alliance: www.globus.org

--
ogsa-hpcp-wg mailing list
ogsa-hpcp-wg@ogf.org
http://www.ogf.org/mailman/listinfo/ogsa-hpcp-wg