With a 2-year celebration of this WG and the recent recharter, I would like to look back and see that we haven't left too much unfinished business behind, or that something is not forgotten. Could you please comment on current document status for this WG? I noticed that the attributes document refers to the "OGSA Authorization Requirements" doc. I guess that should read GFD.38 (the work done by authz-wg)? In addition, from what I can tell the first version of the SAML callout spec haven't hit the editor yet. I had the impression that was about to happen "any day now" -- or are you skipping this and shooting for the SAMLv2 version of the document immediately? Cleaning-ladily yours, /Olle
Olle, I thought the Authorization service document was in your/Dane's hands to pass to the editor. Maybe I am misremembering the process and I'm supposed to submit it? In any case there is the requested tweak from the OGSA-WG from my email yesterday now, so maybe its best it hasn't progressed. The requirements document is actually the following document, which is an informational document that was created when we split the authz svc and atribbutes documents. It should progress as well. https://forge.gridforum.org/docman2/ViewCategory.php? group_id=119&category_id=449 The attributes document is in public comment:
The OGSA Attributes document is now in public comment so people are encouraged to read and comment on that as well. http://www.ggf.org/Public_Comment_Docs/Documents/July-2005/draft- ggf-OGSA-authorization-attributes-june-05.pdf
Von On Aug 16, 2005, at 4:39 AM, Olle Mulmo wrote:
With a 2-year celebration of this WG and the recent recharter, I would like to look back and see that we haven't left too much unfinished business behind, or that something is not forgotten. Could you please comment on current document status for this WG?
I noticed that the attributes document refers to the "OGSA Authorization Requirements" doc. I guess that should read GFD.38 (the work done by authz-wg)?
In addition, from what I can tell the first version of the SAML callout spec haven't hit the editor yet. I had the impression that was about to happen "any day now" -- or are you skipping this and shooting for the SAMLv2 version of the document immediately?
Cleaning-ladily yours,
/Olle
Ahaaa... that explains things. Actually, an author can submit a document to the Editor pipeline him/herself ("Submit GGF draft" in the Editor project at GridForge). But if you want to, I can take care of that for you. Would it make sense to "upgrade" the OGSI technology references in the requirements document and instead refer to the current OGSA base profile technology (WSRF/WSN) before progressing the document? Basically it's just a question of word replacements, as I see it the requirements are the same. That would make the document "current" and "hot" and "useful" and be time well spent: I see little value in using the publishing process as an archival service. /Olle -----Original Message----- From: Von Welch [mailto:vwelch@ncsa.uiuc.edu] Sent: Tuesday, August 16, 2005 4:50 PM To: Olle Mulmo Cc: ogsa-authz@ggf.org Subject: Re: [OGSA-AUTHZ] Q on document status Olle, I thought the Authorization service document was in your/Dane's hands to pass to the editor. Maybe I am misremembering the process and I'm supposed to submit it? In any case there is the requested tweak from the OGSA-WG from my email yesterday now, so maybe its best it hasn't progressed. The requirements document is actually the following document, which is an informational document that was created when we split the authz svc and atribbutes documents. It should progress as well. https://forge.gridforum.org/docman2/ViewCategory.php? group_id=119&category_id=449 The attributes document is in public comment:
The OGSA Attributes document is now in public comment so people are encouraged to read and comment on that as well. http://www.ggf.org/Public_Comment_Docs/Documents/July-2005/draft- ggf-OGSA-authorization-attributes-june-05.pdf
Von On Aug 16, 2005, at 4:39 AM, Olle Mulmo wrote:
With a 2-year celebration of this WG and the recent recharter, I would like to look back and see that we haven't left too much unfinished business behind, or that something is not forgotten. Could you please comment on current document status for this WG?
I noticed that the attributes document refers to the "OGSA Authorization Requirements" doc. I guess that should read GFD.38 (the work done by authz-wg)?
In addition, from what I can tell the first version of the SAML callout spec haven't hit the editor yet. I had the impression that was about to happen "any day now" -- or are you skipping this and shooting for the SAMLv2 version of the document immediately?
Cleaning-ladily yours,
/Olle
On Aug 16, 2005, at 12:54 PM, Olle Mulmo wrote:
Ahaaa... that explains things. Actually, an author can submit a document to the Editor pipeline him/herself ("Submit GGF draft" in the Editor project at GridForge). But if you want to, I can take care of that for you.
Ah, I think Dane did it for the attributes document. I can take care of it.
Would it make sense to "upgrade" the OGSI technology references in the requirements document and instead refer to the current OGSA base profile technology (WSRF/WSN) before progressing the document? Basically it's just a question of word replacements, as I see it the requirements are the same. That would make the document "current" and "hot" and "useful" and be time well spent: I see little value in using the publishing process as an archival service.
Here's the original, is that what you mean? https://forge.gridforum.org/projects/ogsa-authz/document/ OGSA_Authorization_Requirements/en/1 Von
/Olle
-----Original Message----- From: Von Welch [mailto:vwelch@ncsa.uiuc.edu] Sent: Tuesday, August 16, 2005 4:50 PM To: Olle Mulmo Cc: ogsa-authz@ggf.org Subject: Re: [OGSA-AUTHZ] Q on document status
Olle,
I thought the Authorization service document was in your/Dane's hands to pass to the editor. Maybe I am misremembering the process and I'm supposed to submit it? In any case there is the requested tweak from the OGSA-WG from my email yesterday now, so maybe its best it hasn't progressed.
The requirements document is actually the following document, which is an informational document that was created when we split the authz svc and atribbutes documents. It should progress as well.
https://forge.gridforum.org/docman2/ViewCategory.php? group_id=119&category_id=449
The attributes document is in public comment:
The OGSA Attributes document is now in public comment so people are encouraged to read and comment on that as well. http://www.ggf.org/Public_Comment_Docs/Documents/July-2005/draft- ggf-OGSA-authorization-attributes-june-05.pdf
Von
On Aug 16, 2005, at 4:39 AM, Olle Mulmo wrote:
With a 2-year celebration of this WG and the recent recharter, I would like to look back and see that we haven't left too much unfinished business behind, or that something is not forgotten. Could you please comment on current document status for this WG?
I noticed that the attributes document refers to the "OGSA Authorization Requirements" doc. I guess that should read GFD.38 (the work done by authz-wg)?
In addition, from what I can tell the first version of the SAML callout spec haven't hit the editor yet. I had the impression that was about to happen "any day now" -- or are you skipping this and shooting for the SAMLv2 version of the document immediately?
Cleaning-ladily yours,
/Olle
participants (2)
-
Olle Mulmo -
Von Welch