March 2011 - occi-wg - lists.ogf.org

OCCI talk for Cloudscape III
by Alan Sill 14 Mar '11

14 Mar '11

Please make any comments... I will give this to Nick in the morning. Alan

3 2

Re: [occi-wg] occi-wg Digest, Vol 24, Issue 13
by Eugene Luster 12 Mar '11

12 Mar '11

Hello all, I agree with Gary. <...prepare for a nano-rant...and one caveat> Caveat: Bob and Cary persevered against a challenging timetable and incorporating many suggestions (and likely lost a bit of sleep) to submit this paper on time. Under these circumstances, it is a job well done. To reinforce, this paper is like a cloud computing RA shopping list. It is a "melange" (I hope this means what I think it means) of reference architecture concepts from both SDOs and commercial bodies. Though this paper is not as focused as I would desire, it attempts to present NIST with valuable ideas to ponder. I would like NIST to consider modifying the diagram similar with Michael's suggestion though I differ a bit with regards to security. My concept for security ideally, would be more pervasive. Perhaps a blanket covering all aspects. The OCCI wg holds enough independent SDO prestige that any suggestions would be well considered by NIST. So if you have any recommendations, please send them to Alan (Mr. Sills has been working a very difficult path guiding NIST, if someone actually sees Alan, please pat him on the back for me) or this wg. If I can get home from Japan, I will send in recommendations. Take care, Eugene On Mar 12, 2011 4:29 AM, <occi-wg-request(a)ogf.org> wrote:

2 1

Fwd: NIST RAAT's comments and recommendations
by Alan Sill 11 Mar '11

11 Mar '11

The NIST Reference Architecture Analysis Team is wrapping up its work as input for the report to be prepared prior to the upcoming NIST Cloud Computing Forum and Workshop III. The attached represents the current output of the analysis team. Can the OCCI OGF work group members please look this over and offer any insight or comments that may come to mind, please? We need this ASAP. Thanks, Alan Begin forwarded message: > From: Babak Jahromi <babakj(a)microsoft.com> > Date: March 11, 2011 12:00:45 PM CST > To: Hung Nguyen <Hung.Nguyen(a)nara.gov>, "micheledrgon(a)dataprobity.com" <micheledrgon(a)dataprobity.com>, "garymazzaferro(a)gmail.com" <garymazzaferro(a)gmail.com>, "Stavinoha Ken <kstavino(a)mail.com" <Stavinoha Ken <kstavino(a)mail.com>, Gregg Brown <greggb(a)microsoft.com>, "John V. Messina" <john.messina(a)nist.gov>, Frederic de Vaulx <f.devaulx(a)prometheuscomputing.com>, "Sill, Alan" <alan.sill(a)ttu.edu>, Cary Landis <clandis(a)virtualglobal.com> > Cc: "Robert B. Bohn" <robert.bohn(a)nist.gov> > Subject: RE: RAAT's comments and recommendations > > Hung, > > My comments are added to the attached files. Overall, it is a great job done, everyone! > > Thanks, > > Babak > > > > From: Hung Nguyen [mailto:Hung.Nguyen@nara.gov] > Sent: Friday, March 11, 2011 6:18 AM > To: micheledrgon(a)dataprobity.com; garymazzaferro(a)gmail.com; Stavinoha Ken <kstavino(a)mail.com; Babak Jahromi; Gregg Brown; John V. Messina; Frederic de Vaulx; Alan Sill; Cary Landis > Cc: Robert B. Bohn > Subject: RE: RAAT's comments and recommendations > > > Good morning RAAT members, > > I hope you are doing great. I copied you in my reply to Bob's email earlier this week. I just want to remind you that this will be our last opportunity to enhance our comments and recommendations. Please feel free to add and make changes to the attached document. > > I've asked Bob to give our team until 3/14 to finalize the document. > > Thanks, > Hung > > >>> Hung Nguyen 3/9/2011 2:55 PM >>> > Hello Bob, > > I hope you are doing great. Thank you very much for your question. Based on the RAAT's diverse in opinions at Monday's meeting, I think the team will have to tweak version v0.5 report before we submit the finalized version as v1.0. > > Please give us until Monday 3/14/11 to incorporate all the changes that were discussed this past Monday. > > RAAT members: Please let Gregg and I know of your final comments before the report is submitted to Bob as the final deliverable. > > Thanks, > Hung > > >>> "Bohn, Robert B." <robert.bohn(a)nist.gov> 3/9/2011 2:29 PM >>> > Hung, > > Quick question about the naming convention on your report. I see it ends in “v0.5”. Is this a final version of your deliverable or version 0.5? > > Frankly, I would like to call it your team’s final copy since we will be working on the developing questions based off of the recommendations. > > > > -Bob > From: Hung Nguyen [mailto:Hung.Nguyen@nara.gov] > Sent: Friday, March 04, 2011 1:15 PM > To: PStingley(a)blm.gov; micheledrgon(a)dataprobity.com; marlin.pohlman(a)emc.com; Bob Marcus; Eugene Luster; garymazzaferro(a)gmail.com; Ken Stavinoha; Randy Baklini; TYoung(a)icfi.com; Anne Fratzen; Dean Kemp; babakj(a)microsoft.com; Gregg Brown; Hung Nguyen; Frederic de Vaulx; Alan Sill; Cary Landis > Cc: Bohn, Robert B. > Subject: RAAT's comments and recommendations > > > Good afternoon Reference Architecture Analysis Team (RAAT) members, > > Based on your analyses and comments, the attached is a MS Word document containing our draft comments and recommendations. Gregg Brown will lead the discussion on Monday, March 7. Please let Gregg and I know if you have additional comments or recommendations after Monday's meeting. > > On behalf of Bob Bohn, I would like to thank you for your hard work, time, and effort. I would like to also recognize Cary Landis for his inputs and help in QAing the draft document. > > Thanks again and have a pleasant weekend. > > Sincerely, > Hung Nguyen. > >

4 5

Core and Infrastructure Documents
by Edmonds, AndrewX 10 Mar '11

10 Mar '11

Hi all, These documents (latest renderings attached) are due to be submitted to the OGF editor pipeline to become OGF recommended documents. We will submit them EOB (CET) Thursday. If there are people here that have time to read through the documents looking for any final issues (conceptual, grammatical etc) that effort would be highly appreciated. Also if there are people here who are missing from the documents contributor list please reply directly to me and I'll sort it out. Thanks Andy ------------------------------------------------------------- Intel Ireland Limited (Branch) Collinstown Industrial Park, Leixlip, County Kildare, Ireland Registered Number: E902934 This e-mail and any attachments may contain confidential material for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any review or distribution by others is strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender and delete all copies.

2 2

no call today
by Thijs Metsch 09 Mar '11

09 Mar '11

Can't open the bridge today - sorry guys! Please feel free to read the current PDF versions of our documents - it would greatly help to remove the last (hopefully) minor issues and get those documents out there. Many thanks, -Thijs

1 0

OCCI use cases and adoption document, FYI
by Alan Sill 04 Mar '11

04 Mar '11

SIENA requested a brief statement on adoption use cases and the design of the OCCI specification set for their roadmapping effort. As this is applicable to the current NIST cloud standards roadmap document development, I have written one and attach it here as a submission also to the NIST document. Please feel free to offer any feedback or requests for changes for incorporation into the above efforts. Thanks, Alan Alan Sill, Ph.D Senior Scientist, High Performance Computing Center Adjunct Professor of Physics, TTU Vice President of Standards, Open Grid Forum ==================================================================== : Alan Sill, Texas Tech University Office: Drane 162, MS 4-1167 : : e-mail: Alan.Sill(a)ttu.edu ph. 806-742-4350 fax 806-742-4358 : ====================================================================

1 0

Invitation to Key Cloud computing event: Cloudscape III - 15-16 March 2011, Brussels
by Johannes Watzl 04 Mar '11

04 Mar '11

Dear all, I am writing to invite you to the Cloudscape III event: Taking European Cloud Infrastructure Forward, 15 & 16 March 2011, The Hotel (formerly the Hilton), Brussels. Organised by the EC-funded *SIENA * <http://www.sienainitiative.eu/Default.aspx>(Standards and Interoperability for eInfrastructure Implementation Initiative) project, Cloudscape III is the perfect opportunity for experts, developers and end-users in the cloud computing space to become part of the cloud standards process. The event is the culmination of 8 months hard work by SIENA of delivering both an invigorating and stimulating agenda. We are also delighted to announce that*Robert Madelin, DG INFSO Director-General* will open Cloudscape III with a keynote presentation. *Dawn Leaf, Senior Advisor NIST Information Technology Laboratory & Senior Executive for Cloud Computing, NIST* will also be giving a key presentation at the event. Their participation is a clear recognition of the work of SIENA and in particular the importance of the SIENA European Roadmap on Grid and Cloud Standards for e-Science and Beyond, the first iteration of which will be launched at the event. The *SIENA European Roadmap on Grid and Cloud Standards for e-Science and Beyond*, focuses on interoperability and standards with the long-term goal of delivering a policy framework for distributed computing that ensures fair competition and adherence to European strategic priorities. To help achieve these goals, the SIENA consortium is taking advantage of Cloudscape-III to showcase speakers from all over the globe in offering their personal insights on specific use cases or interoperability issues surrounding Cloud computing. The *use cases* will make up part of the final roadmap scenarios to identify drivers for change. Specific emphasis during a packed agenda will also be placed on legal & ethical issues, data privacy, security and the legal side of portability inviting experts in those areas to present as well as to participate. Registration for the event also covers two-days of *presentations *and*Round Tables* led by international experts, developers and users, a *Welcome Cocktail *sponsored by Microsoft Research with demos, networking lunches and coffee breaks, along with a special set of resources for attendees. With Cloud computing is expected to play a key role in the digital economy in Europe and beyond, I hope that you will be able to participate at this key event. You can *register *for Cloudscape III here <http://www.sienainitiative.eu/Pages/EventRegistrationForm.aspx?idevent=b3f3…>and find out more about the event at this link <http://www.sienainitiative.eu/Pages/SelectedDocument.aspx?id_documento=b3f3…>. I also attach the latest working agenda for your convenience. Please do not hesitate to contact me for any further information. Best regards Johannes Watzl *About SIENA* SIENA (the Standards and Interoperability for eInfrastructure Implementation Initiative) is contributing to defining a future eInfrastructures roadmap in close collaboration with the European Commission and synthesizing viewpoints from EC-funded DCI projects and Standards Development Organisations active in the Distributed Computing Infrastructure environment. The SIENA European Roadmap on Grid and Cloud Standards for e-Science and Beyond is being created by the SIENA Roadmap Editorial Board made up of representatives from DCI projects, SDOs, grid and cloud research experts and user community representatives. *About Cloudscape III - *Cloudscape III is the third in a series of annual cloud computing workshop that places European priorities centre stage to strengthen the collective voice and deepen ties with all major stakeholders. The event will include a series of use-cases highlighting best practices and challenges faced by both cloud providers and end-users, while roundtable discussions will offer a springboard for participants to join the debate and help formulate a view of the future landscape of services. The Workshop offers ample opportunities to network with EC representatives, cloud computing experts from the SIENA Roadmap and Editorial Board, as well as representatives from standards groups, industry and eScience.

1 0

Re: [occi-wg] SGCC Standards Analysis Work Team - a draft volunteer list for analaysis work
by Alan Sill 04 Mar '11

04 Mar '11

Thanks, Mark. I am not sure that I understand the table marked "Synthesis" or its labeling. It may be appropriate to check the additional columns for "Cloud management," "Platform APIs" and "Infrastructure APIs" as I have done in the attached copy. The OCCI-WG participants may wish to comment further. I appreciate the opportunity and hour help with our response. Alan On Mar 3, 2011, at 10:38 PM, Mark Carlson wrote: > Alan, > > This is what I will send Dr. Lee for OGF. > > -- mark > > On 3/2/11 8:21 PM, Mark Carlson wrote: >> Alan, >> >> Actually the convener is trying to get all responses in by tomorrow >> so he can consolidate by the March 7th deadline. >> >> I would just put the 3 OCCI documents in for now since time is short. >> There will be other opportunities later to add others. >> >> -- mark >> >> On 3/2/11 6:57 PM, 刘娜 wrote: >>>> Hi Alan & others , >>>> >>>> Thanks for your reply. OGF is one of the excellent standardization organizations like other workers,we are very concerned of it. As members of SGCC standards Analysis work teame，we are more concerned about published specifications on cloud computing. >>>> >>>> Here,thanks Mark for introducing you to us. In the volunteer list for analyzing publications of SDOs on cloud computing , Mark is the volunteer of OGF. Mrs. Wang jieping and I want to cooperate. So, we hope Mark give the distribution of the job. :) >>>> >>>> The due date for response is March,7. I think Mr. Mark have sent you the template doucument which is discussed on teleconference by SGCC standards Analysis Work Team. If the experts of OGF respond in the format is a good idea. >>>> >>>> As far as I know,in the N0126 document of SC38，OGF has two publications about cloud computing.And closer to the deadline, what the opinion of Mr. Mark? Thanks. >>>> >>>> We are not able to attend OGF 31, but we can communicate by e-mail. >>>> >>> Thanks again. >>> >>> Best regards, >>> Kathy liu >>> >>>> Liuna (Kathy) >>>> >>> CESI (China electronics Standardization Institute) >>> Tel：86-10-84029108 >>> fax:86-10-64007803 >>> Mob:86-10-13521677086 >>> >>> http://www.cesi.ac.cn >>>> >>>> -----原始邮件----- >>>> >>>>> 发件人: "Alan Sill" <alan.sill(a)ttu.edu> >>>>> >>>>> 发送时间: 2011-03-03 03:38:36 >>>>> 收件人: "刘娜" >>>>> <liuna(a)cesi.ac.cn> >>>>> >>>>> 抄送: "Alan Sill" >>>>> <alan.sill(a)ttu.edu>,"Mark Carlson" <mark.carlson(a)oracle.com>,"Joel Replogle" <replogle(a)ogf.org>,wangjieping <wangjieping(a)cesi.ac.cn>,"이승윤" <syl(a)etri.re.kr> >>>>> >>>>> 主题: Re: SGCC Standards Analysis Work Team - a draft volunteer list for analaysis work >>>>> >>>>> Hi Kathy and others, >>>>> >>>>> Thanks very much for your inquiry egarding OGF standards. In order to >>>>> respond properly and in a timely way to your request, I would like to >>>>> ask for a small bit of context. >>>>> >>>>> (1) What sort of standards are you interested in cataloging? OGF has >>>>> over 40 published specifications in the formal P-REC or REC status >>>>> (proposed or full recommendations) published in the GFD series. (GFD >>>>> stands for "Grid Final Document.") If we expand to include experience >>>>> documents, informational documents, etc. we have now nearly 180 >>>>> formally published GFDs. These range from small-scale reviews of use >>>>> cases to extensive and exhaustive comparisons of implementations of >>>>> various published specifications. >>>>> >>>>> (2) What other information about OGF as an SDO do you need? >>>>> >>>>> (3) What is the timescale for response to this inquiry? Is there any >>>>> other form than this one, or do you want us to respond in the format >>>>> that you provided? >>>>> >>>>> You mentioned there are two volunteers including you who want to reply >>>>> regarding input from OGF. How can I assist in this effort? >>>>> >>>>> I hope we can discuss this in person perhaps at the upcoming >>>>> International Symposium on Grids and Clouds (ISGC 2011) at which we >>>>> are, as perhaps you know, co-locating the OGF 31 conference March >>>>> 21-25 in Taipei. If you need a response earlier than this, or are not >>>>> able to attend OGF 31, we can communicate by e-mail. >>>>> >>>>> Please let me know how I can assist in this endeavor. >>>>> >>>>> Alan Sill, Ph.D >>>>> Senior Scientist, High Performance Computing Center >>>>> Adjunct Professor of Physics, TTU >>>>> Vice President of Standards, Open Grid Forum >>>>> >>>>> ==================================================================== >>>>> : Alan Sill, Texas Tech University Office: Drane 162, MS 4-1167 : >>>>> : e-mail: >>>>> Alan.Sill(a)ttu.edu >>>>> ph. 806-742-4350 fax 806-742-4358 : >>>>> ==================================================================== >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> On Feb 25, 2011, at 6:55 AM, Mark Carlson wrote: >>>>> >>>>> > That is great. >>>>> > >>>>> > Let me introduce you to Alan Sill, CTO of OGF. >>>>> > >>>>> > Alan, as part of the ISO/IEC JTC 1 SC38 Study Group on >>>>> > Cloud Computing we are filling out a template for OGF >>>>> > that includes the cloud related specifications and their >>>>> > details from your organization. >>>>> > >>>>> > If you have a comprehensive list we could work from, >>>>> > that would make it easier. >>>>> > >>>>> > Thanks, >>>>> > >>>>> > -- mark >>>>> > >>>>> > On 2/24/11 6:39 PM, 刘娜 wrote: >>>>> >> >>>>> >> >>>>> >> >>>>> >> >>>>> >> >>>>> >> >>>>> >> Hi,Mark >>>>> >> >>>>> >> Thanks for your reply. I am pleased to work together. I >>>>> >> explain one thing, Ms. Wang Jieping(China) and I (China) both >>>>> >> volunteered to provide input for OGF. We got a good news that now >>>>> >> there were two volunteers wanted to collaborate with you. What >>>>> >> about your opinion? Thanks. >>>>> >> >>>>> >> Best regards, >>>>> >> >>>>> >> Kathy Liu >>>>> >> >>>>> >> -----原始邮件----- >>>>> >> 发件人: "Mark Carlson" >>>>> <mark.carlson(a)oracle.com> >>>>> >>>>> >> 发送时间: 2011-02-25 00:47:57 >>>>> >> 收件人: "이승윤" >>>>> <syl(a)etri.re.kr> >>>>> >>>>> >> 抄送: "刘娜" >>>>> <liuna(a)cesi.ac.cn> >>>>> >>>>> >> 主题: Re: SGCC Standards Analysis Work Team - a draft volunteer >>>>> >> list for analaysis work >>>>> >> >>>>> >> Be happy to. I can also just defer to Liu as I was mainly >>>>> >> concerned that nobody had volunteered so far, and now >>>>> >> there is a volunteer. >>>>> >> >>>>> >> Thanks, >>>>> >> -- mark >>>>> >> >>>>> >> On 2/24/11 9:41 AM, 이승윤 wrote: >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Hi Liu and Mark, >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Regarding of OGF, there are two volunteers from US and China. >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> If you don’t mind, I hope you guys work together : ) >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Best regards, >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Seungyun >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> From: 刘娜 [ >>>>> mailto:liuna@CESI.AC.CN >>>>> ] >>>>> >>> Sent: Thursday, February 24, 2011 11:36 AM >>>>> >>> To: >>>>> SC38SGCC(a)MAILLIST.ANSI.ORG >>>>> >>>>> >>> Subject: Re: SGCC Standards Analysis Work Team - a draft volunteer >>>>> >>> list for analaysis work >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Dear all, >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> It is a pity I cannot dial in the teleconference >>>>> >>> yesterday . I and Ms. Wang jieping volunteered to provide the >>>>> >>> input for OGF and Other Standards Organizations , CESI , the >>>>> >>> corresponding standardization work about CC of China electronics >>>>> >>> Standardization Institute . >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> ! --Kathy Liu >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Liuna (Kathy) >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> CESI (China electronics Standardization Institute) >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Tel：86-10-84029108 >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> fax:86-10-64007803 >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Mob:86-10-13521677086 >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> http://www.cesi.ac.cn >>>>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> From: 이승윤 [ >>>>> mailto:syl@ETRI.RE.KR >>>>> ] >>>>> >>> Sent: Thursday, February 24, 2011 2:06 AM >>>>> >>> To: >>>>> SC38SGCC(a)MAILLIST.ANSI.ORG >>>>> >>>>> >>> Subject: SGCC Standards Analysis Work Team - a draft volunteer >>>>> >>> list for analaysis work >>>>> >>> Importance: High >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Dear folks, >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> First of all, I would like to thank all participant for today’s >>>>> >>> call. >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> According to today’s meeting results of 2nd teleconference of >>>>> >>> SGCC Standards Analysis work team, it was agreed that the work >>>>> >>> team will develop the SDO comparison using proposed template (SC38 >>>>> >>> N0148). In doing so, it is need to identify a volunteer who fill >>>>> >>> up the contents to the propose template. I enclose a draft >>>>> >>> volunteer list as attached and it needs to be completed. It would >>>>> >>> be welcomed if you provide a relevant expert for missing parts. >>>>> >>> So, please confirm the current volunteer list and hope you could >>>>> >>> recommend some volunteer for missing parts by tomorrow, 25 >>>>> >>> February 2011. >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> I enclosed the word format of proposed template (SC38 N0148) as a >>>>> >>> second attachment. Today’s meeting also agreed! to fill up the >>>>> >>> content in volunteer basis. Please send your contents to leader of >>>>> >>> this work team (SGCC Convenor) by Thursday, 3 March 2011. I will >>>>> >>> incorporate and re-circulate them before 7 March, 2011. >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Finally, please check the membership list of SGCC as a third >>>>> >>> attachment. If there is something to be updated on membership >>>>> >>> list, please let me and secretary (Mr. Zhou Ping) know it. >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Ps. I will distribute the today’s meeting report soon as well. >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Best regards, >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> Seungyun Lee >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> A convener of SC38 SGCC >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> To unsubscribe from the SC38SGCC list, click the following link: >>>>> >>> &*TICKET_URL(SC38SGCC,SIGNOFF); >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> To unsubscribe from the SC38SGCC list, click the following link: >>>>> >>> &*TICKET_URL(SC38SGCC,SIGNOFF); >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> -- >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> >>>>> >>> To unsubscribe from the SC38SGCC list, click the following link: >>>>> >>> &*TICKET_URL(SC38SGCC,SIGNOFF); >>>>> >>> >>>>> >> >>>>> >>> Liuna (Kathy) >>> CESI (China electronics Standardization Institute) >>> Tel：86-10-84029108 >>> fax:86-10-64007803 >>> Mob:86-10-13521677086 >>> >>> http://www.cesi.ac.cn

1 0

IBM contribution of its Cloud Computing Reference Architecture and references to CCMP
by Alan Sill 03 Mar '11

03 Mar '11

Dear OCCI-WG, An exercise of mapping of OCCI functionalities onto the proposed Common Cloud Management Platform (CCMP) features could be an interesting thing to do. I am not sure whether IBM is proposing CCMP as a ne standard, as a product, or just in the context of an architectural model; however, it seems well-enough described to compare with OCCI. Just a suggestion... Alan Begin forwarded message: > From: Christopher B Ferris <chrisfer(a)us.ibm.com> > Date: February 28, 2011 5:45:12 PM CST > To: Multiple recipients of list <cc_refarch(a)nist.gov> > Subject: Re: Latest Cloud Computing RA Conceptual Model > Reply-To: "cc_refarch(a)nist.gov" <cc_refarch(a)nist.gov> > > Today, IBM made a contribution of it's Cloud Computing Reference > Architecture (CCRA) version 2.0 to The Open Group's > (TOG) Cloud Computing Architecture Project. > > Given that certain aspects of the evolving NIST RA were derived from > an early version of > IBM's CCRA (v1), there may be interest in our latest thinking. > > The public contribution document can be downloaded from here: > http://www.opengroup.org/cloudcomputing/documents.tpl?CALLER=index.tpl&dcat… > > Cheers, > > Christopher Ferris > IBM Distinguished Engineer, CTO Industry and Cloud Standards > Member, IBM Academy of Technology > IBM Software Group, Standards Strategy > email: chrisfer(a)us.ibm.com > blog: https://www.ibm.com/developerworks/mydeveloperworks/blogs/chrisferris/ > phone: +1 508 234 2986 > > -----cc_refarch(a)nist.gov wrote: ----- > To: Multiple recipients of list <cc_refarch(a)nist.gov> > From: "Bohn, Robert B." > Sent by: cc_refarch(a)nist.gov > Date: 02/28/2011 06:25PM > Subject: Latest Cloud Computing RA Conceptual Model > > All: > > > > > > I have included changes from today’s discussion. Please let me know > if you think anything has been missed. I wish to send this to the > Standards Working Group. > > > > Thanks! > > > > -b > > > > [attachment "Strawman model v2.pdf" removed by Christopher B Ferris/ > Waltham/IBM] > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ If > you would like to unsubscribe from cc_refarch, please send an email > to listproc(a)nist.gov with a message body of: unsubscribe cc_refarch > Please note: you must send the message from the account that you are > subscribed. Begin forwarded message: > From: "Bohn, Robert B." <robert.bohn(a)nist.gov> > Date: February 28, 2011 5:13:33 PM CST > To: Multiple recipients of list <cc_refarch(a)nist.gov> > Subject: Latest Cloud Computing RA Conceptual Model > Reply-To: "cc_refarch(a)nist.gov" <cc_refarch(a)nist.gov> > > All: > > > > > > I have included changes from today’s discussion. Please let me know > if you think anything has been missed. I wish to send this to the > Standards Working Group. > > > > Thanks! > > > > -b >

2 2

cloud-standards.org entries for OCCI updated
by Alan Sill 03 Mar '11

03 Mar '11

After considerable prodding from Mark ;-) I have updated the entries for OGF and for the three current near-release OCCI documents in the table at http://cloud-standards.org Here is what I put in. If you would like further details or changes, let me or Mark know, or ask for an account. I'll try to add explicit references once the current OCCI-WG documents make it through the OGF pipeline (hopefully soon - we are waiting for your document edits after the review period on the first two!). Alan Alan Sill, Ph.D Senior Scientist, High Performance Computing Center Adjunct Professor of Physics, TTU Vice President of Standards, Open Grid Forum ==================================================================== : Alan Sill, Texas Tech University Office: Drane 162, MS 4-1167 : : e-mail: Alan.Sill(a)ttu.edu ph. 806-742-4350 fax 806-742-4358 : ====================================================================

3 3