Hello All, Please find below the results of the vote for the NSI topology distribution proposals. UvA/Miroslav NORDUnet/Henrik ESnet/John Guy R. GÉANT 1 Diederik V. SURFsara 1 Chin G. ESnet 1 Hans T Surfnet 1 Henrik TJ. Nordunet 1 Miroslav Z. UvA 1 Tomohiro K. AIST 1 John M. ESnet 1 Michal b PSNC/GÉANT 1 Artur J. PSNC/GÉANT 1 Freek D SURFsara 1 Total 3 1 7 Please find the preferred proposal from John MacAuley here: https://redmine.ogf.org/dmsf_files/13243 I look forward to seeing you all in Washington on Wednesday. Guy _____________________________________________________________________ Guy Roberts PhD Senior Transport Network Architect GEANT Limited Email: guy.roberts@dante.net<mailto:guy.roberts@dante.net> Tel: +44 (0)1223 371316 Mob: +44 (0)7881 336417 GEANT Limited is part of the GÉANT Association Networking. Services. People Learn more at: www.geant.org<http://www.geant.org/> and www.dante.net<http://www.dante.net/> GEANT Limited registered in England & Wales. Registration Number 2806796. Registered Office - City House, 126-130 Hills Road, Cambridge CB2 1PQ _____________________________________________________________________
On 20-3-2015 18:30, Guy Roberts wrote:
Please find below the results of the vote for the NSI topology distribution proposals.
Congrats John, As I mailed the chairs, I think the UvA and ESnet proposal are fairly similar, and I certainly appreciate the clarity that this vote has brought. For what it's worth, this is what I considered the key points of each proposal: Miroslav's proposal adds one indirection (distribute URL's instead of topologies itself). This may be beneficial if the originator likes to expose different topologies based on the recipient. John's proposal can also distribute other information (documents). Henrik's proposal has a clear vision on how to deal with policies: by distributing reachability instead of distributing topologies. I hope that the strong points of each proposal may benefit in future discussion on how to deal with different policies. I thank the chairs for organizing this vote as a way to provide clarity and move forward. Regards, Freek
participants (2)
-
Freek Dijkstra -
Guy Roberts