Comment-ID Title Posted By Status Resolution/Discussion
1 Changing Offers Toshiyuki Nakata Resolved Treat the normative part as correct.
2 Minor comments & asynchronous operations[ Reply ] Takuya Araki On discussion Discuss on the mailing-list.
(especially wrt . Having it in the protocol or having it in the bindings)
3 Semantics of related agreements ill-defined[ Reply ] Heiko Ludwig (GGF12) On discussion Discuss on the mailing-list. (esp. Necessity vs.keeping the spec. simple)
4 How do we know that terms are fulfilled?[ Reply ] Heiko Ludwig (GGF12) Resolved (15thFeb) It cannot be enforced..(I will give a more detailed summary after I read the minutes)
5 Why is the termination time part of context?[ Reply ] Heiko Ludwig (GGF12) Resolved Because the expiration time refers to the whole of Agreement. A simple expanation will be added?
6 ZeroOrMore needed[ Reply ] Heiko Ludwig (GGF12) Resolved Unless someone gives a clear Usecase of how this term is used, stick to the current proposal.
7 Specification too complex[ Reply ] Heiko Ludwig (GGF12) Resolved In a sense we have been simplifying the spec by giving up on related agreements etc.
8 AgreementIsProvider attribute[ Reply ] Heiko Ludwig (GGF12) Resolved Add some more explanation to really define the role of Agreement Provider and Service Provider etc.
9 Related Agreements and Brokers[ Reply ] Heiko Ludwig (GGF12) To Be Discussed  
10 Referred Specs[ Reply ] Komori Hitoshi To Be Discussed  
11 Three "nits" Jon MacLaren To Be Discussed  
12 WS-Agreement spec - proposed refactoring Jon MacLaren To Be Discussed  
13 Consistency of WSRF ResProp. based monitoring Jon MacLaren To Be Discussed  
14 WS-Agreement dependent on less mature specs Jon MacLaren To Be Discussed  
15 Use of WS-ResourceProperties Jon MacLaren To Be Discussed  
16 Organisation of runtime monitoring material Jon MacLaren To Be Discussed  
17 No XML snippets for Resource Properties in S8 Jon MacLaren To Be Discussed  
18 Inconsistent use of expiration / termination Jon MacLaren To Be Discussed  
19 Figure 2    Tiziana Ferrari To Be Discussed  
20 glossary and Figure 1    Tiziana Ferrari To Be Discussed  
21  comments about Section 7 (run time states)    Tiziana Ferrari To Be Discussed  
22 definition of compliance in Section 6    Tiziana Ferrari To Be Discussed  
23  Language problem in Section 5.1.1    Tiziana Ferrari To Be Discussed  
24 creation contraints and serv. lev. Objectives    Tiziana Ferrari To Be Discussed  
25  Occurance of AssessmentInterval in Comp.Type Heiko Ludwig To Be Discussed