
Hello, in the public comment version of GLUE 2.0, two kinds of DNs (Distinguished Names) with different delimiters are specified. Section 16.3.8 defines as DNs: "X509 uses a X500 namespace represented as several Relative Domain-Names (RDNs) concatenated by forward-slashes". A slash-separated DN notation is also used in the examples throughout the document. I was not able to find such a definition in the X509 spec. As X509 stay rather general, are you sure it implements a forward-slash notation ? Section 17.4., in contrast, defines a DataType DN_T as a RFC 4515 Distinguished name. RFC 4515 says "There is zero or more relative distinguished names, separated by <COMMA>, for a distinguished name." I propose to either - specify both delimiters, fix the X509 citation and state clearly in which cases which notation is to be used, or - decide for the RFC4515 notation (comma separated), which seems to be (better) standardized and rewrite the examples. Also at the beginning of section 16.3.8, the sentence "It must start [...]" (state ?) should be improved. ciao, Timo Dipl-Inf. Timo Baur Leibniz Rechenzentrum Kommunikationsnetze/Netzplanung/D-MON Boltzmannstr. 1 D-85748 Garching Telefon +49 89 35831-8729 Fax +49 89 35831-5729 timo.baur@lrz-muenchen.de

glue-wg-bounces@ogf.org
[mailto:glue-wg-bounces@ogf.org] On Behalf Of Timo Baur said: in the public comment version of GLUE 2.0, two kinds of DNs (Distinguished Names) with different delimiters are specified.
There are indeed two forms and we have both in use, e.g. ldap uses comma-separated DNs whereas X509 applications generally use the slash-delimited form. They are both derived from the underlying OID representation. I don't know offhand where they are formally defined but no doubt google can find it. In terms of GLUE usage, I would be inclined to say that all DN attributes should be the slash-delimited form, but the LDAP representation will use the comma for the object DNs themselves. Incidentally, there are additional ambiguities, the best-known of which is that there are three different text representations for the "email address" OID (E=, Email= and emailAddress= I think) in common use. I'm not sure if GLUE should take a view on such things. Stephen
participants (2)
-
Burke, S (Stephen)
-
Timo Baur