glue-wg [mailto:glue-wg-bounces@ogf.org] On Behalf Of Baptiste
Grenier said: The names should be quite self explanatory, please let me know if you need any clarification.
A few comments ...
* GLUE2CloudComputingEndpointAuthentication * EndpointAuthentication_t * New type * Mandatory * Open enumeration * Default Values: X509-VOMS, OIDC ? * Replacing: * GLUE2EntityOtherInfo : Authn=X509-VOMS
It's arguable that this should go into the base Endpoint definition as it's potentially useful for anything - although in that case it couldn't be mandatory as that would make all existing objects invalid. If it is mandatory you should probably have a NONE option or similar. Also is anything else needed? For the standard X509 case Endpoint has IssuerCA and TrustedCA, could other authn types need anything more? One other thing, X509-VOMS seems an odd value here since VOMS is about authorization (already covered by the Policy class) and not authentication.
* GLUE2CloudComputingImageDescription * New type * Mandatory * String * Replacing: * GLUE2EntityOtherInfo: description:Image for TinyCoreLinux
It seems slightly odd for a text description to be mandatory.
* GLUE2CloudComputingImageNetworkInput / GLUE2CloudComputingImageNetworkOuput * Used to represent communication ports used/required/exposed by the image * Custom objectClass: NetworkTraffic * Optional * Can be specified multiple times * Replacing: * GLUE2EntityOtherInfo traffic-in:XXXXX * GLUE2EntityOtherInfo traffic-out:XXXXX
This is missing a data type and a clear definition.
* NetworkTrafficProtocol_t: * Custom type * Mandatory * Closed enumeration * Values: all, tcp, udp, cmp, ipsec
Is that certain to be an exhaustive list?
* NetworkTrafficType_t: * Custom type * Mandatory * Closed enumeration * Values: inbound, outbound
TrafficDirection rather than Type? Never bidirectional?
* NetworkTrafficRange_t: * Custom type * Mandatory * String * Example (default?): 0.0.0.0/0
AddressRange rather than just Range?
* NetworkTrafficPort_t: * Custom type * Mandatory * String * Example: 443
Single valued or multivalued? Can it be a range or just a single port? If the latter why a string? Stephen