Hello all Thanks for all replies in regards to my comments.
Because of I posted material about multicast too, I'd like to consider Marinho's proposal related to an integration about current implementations (MDP, NORM, etc.). So if you agree I can do this job with him as a first step of revision.
Marco has written some material about multicast too, and there is a proposal that we discuss the subject and enrich a little the net-issues document in the multicast section with considerations on current reliable multicast implementations. Cheers, Marinho. Prof. Marinho P. Barcellos (marinho at acm dot org)
All: I just got the mail that the original version is approved for publication (GFD-I.37). I propose to continue with our editing and create a secind version that includes the discussed changes and potentially more. Volker Marinho P Barcellos schrieb:
Hello all
Thanks for all replies in regards to my comments.
Because of I posted material about multicast too, I'd like to consider Marinho's proposal related to an integration about current implementations (MDP, NORM, etc.). So if you agree I can do this job with him as a first step of revision.
Marco has written some material about multicast too, and there is a proposal that we discuss the subject and enrich a little the net-issues document in the multicast section with considerations on current reliable multicast implementations.
Cheers, Marinho.
Prof. Marinho P. Barcellos (marinho at acm dot org)
Hello all
On Tuesday 23 November 2004 07:37, Volker Sander wrote: All: I just got the mail that the original version is approved for publication (GFD-I.37). I propose to continue with our editing and create a secind version that includes the discussed changes and potentially more.
Volker, how does this work? I don't know exactly what it means to have the document "approved", then my question is: is it possible to evolve the document to incorporate required corrections, recommended improvements and contents and style, and optional additions? On Friday 19 November 2004 14:44, Volker Sander wrote:
yes, I was also thinking about adding Marinho to the list of authors, so i am with your proposal
I acknowledge that, thank you. On Thursday 18 November 2004 16:07, Marco Tana wrote:
Because of I posted material about multicast too, I'd like to consider Marinho's proposal related to an integration about current implementations (MDP, NORM, etc.). So if you agree I can do this job with him as a first step of revision. I'll come back to my office next Tuesday...so I look forward to reading your remarks and, possibly, the comments addressing plan.
Marco should be back to office now and we will discuss the part about multicast. Could you please get in touch, Marco? Regards, Marinho. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Prof. Marinho P. Barcellos (marinho at acm dot org) University of Manchester and BT Research Labs/UK On leave from UNISINOS University, Brazil ---------------------------------------------------------------------- *** Please avoid sending me Word, PowerPoint or Excel attachments. *** See http://www.fsf.org/philosophy/no-word-attachments.html
I think we can submit a new document that replaces/outdates the existing one. I guess we should take the time to produce a substantially improved version Franco, Jon: What do you think? Volker Marinho P Barcellos schrieb:
Hello all
On Tuesday 23 November 2004 07:37, Volker Sander wrote: All: I just got the mail that the original version is approved for publication (GFD-I.37). I propose to continue with our editing and create a secind version that includes the discussed changes and potentially more.
Volker, how does this work? I don't know exactly what it means to have the document "approved", then my question is: is it possible to evolve the document to incorporate required corrections, recommended improvements and contents and style, and optional additions?
On Friday 19 November 2004 14:44, Volker Sander wrote:
yes, I was also thinking about adding Marinho to the list of authors, so i am with your proposal
I acknowledge that, thank you.
On Thursday 18 November 2004 16:07, Marco Tana wrote:
Because of I posted material about multicast too, I'd like to consider Marinho's proposal related to an integration about current implementations (MDP, NORM, etc.). So if you agree I can do this job with him as a first step of revision. I'll come back to my office next Tuesday...so I look forward to reading your remarks and, possibly, the comments addressing plan.
Marco should be back to office now and we will discuss the part about multicast. Could you please get in touch, Marco?
Regards, Marinho.
---------------------------------------------------------------------- Prof. Marinho P. Barcellos (marinho at acm dot org) University of Manchester and BT Research Labs/UK On leave from UNISINOS University, Brazil ----------------------------------------------------------------------
*** Please avoid sending me Word, PowerPoint or Excel attachments. *** See http://www.fsf.org/philosophy/no-word-attachments.html
With GFDs, the GGF archives immutable documents (same as RFCs in the IETF). The GGF process further notes that: A Grid Forum document may be designated as obsolete when it is superseded by another document. The obsolete designation clearly indicates that the document no longer reflects current thinking, but still recognizes the document's contributions by allowing it to be referenced and consulted. A stronger designation of historical is used, primarily for technical specifications or specific recommendations, to indicate that the specification should no longer be used. In order to change a GFD status to historical, a GFD-I is necessary to explain the reasoning. No doubt, the community is progressing in the understanding of network requirements posed by the Grid, while networking research continues to offer new capabilities ... therefore, it is well worth to a) track all updates to the netissues-4 draft and b) batch them into a substantial new release, which will obsolete GFD.37 and will appear 1 year or 18 months from now. As well, it is possible to create a companion document capturing a deeper dive into one of the subject areas (e.g., multicast for the Grid). -franco At 06:11 AM 11/25/2004, Volker Sander wrote:
I think we can submit a new document that replaces/outdates the existing one. I guess we should take the time to produce a substantially improved version
Franco, Jon: What do you think?
Volker
Marinho P Barcellos schrieb:
Hello all
On Tuesday 23 November 2004 07:37, Volker Sander wrote: All: I just got the mail that the original version is approved for publication (GFD-I.37). I propose to continue with our editing and create a secind version that includes the discussed changes and potentially more.
Volker, how does this work? I don't know exactly what it means to have the document "approved", then my question is: is it possible to evolve the document to incorporate required corrections, recommended improvements and contents and style, and optional additions?
On Friday 19 November 2004 14:44, Volker Sander wrote:
yes, I was also thinking about adding Marinho to the list of authors, so i am with your proposal
I acknowledge that, thank you.
On Thursday 18 November 2004 16:07, Marco Tana wrote:
Because of I posted material about multicast too, I'd like to consider Marinho's proposal related to an integration about current implementations (MDP, NORM, etc.). So if you agree I can do this job with him as a first step of revision. I'll come back to my office next Tuesday...so I look forward to reading your remarks and, possibly, the comments addressing plan.
Marco should be back to office now and we will discuss the part about multicast. Could you please get in touch, Marco?
Regards, Marinho.
---------------------------------------------------------------------- Prof. Marinho P. Barcellos (marinho at acm dot org) University of Manchester and BT Research Labs/UK On leave from UNISINOS University, Brazil ----------------------------------------------------------------------
*** Please avoid sending me Word, PowerPoint or Excel attachments. *** See <http://www.fsf.org/philosophy/no-word-attachments.html>http://www.fsf.org/philosophy/no-word-attachments.html
participants (3)
-
Franco Travostino -
Marinho P Barcellos -
Volker Sander