Hi Stuart, I have two comments about the Test plan: * I think the Test case 4b (Reverse) should expect the components to be terminated in the order (C,B,A). Am I right? * The Notification tests regarding Lifecycle Events (section 3, 1.c.iii) are not clear. When you say "The test should subscribe for all notifications such as OnInitialized...", do you mean a test component? It would be great to have a clear definition of this in the TestPlan and in the ComponentModel document because sections 4.6.3, 4.6.4 and 4.6.5 are not clear. Maybe a test case with notification and another using another "process" would make this more clear. Besides that, in the specification, it is said that the cmp:LifecycleSituation is the only category supported in the ManagementEvent, but we didn't find the definition of this element in the component-model.xsd. We were thinking about do not using the situation in the Event, and of making the System manage the lifecycle operation or the notification to be performed when a component changes its state as it manages all of its components. Then, the System subscribes for the WSDM StateCapability topic in each component and then, in its notify handles what must be done when a component has changed its state (for instance, it can invoke the terminate operatin on component C when component B has failed). ok? Regards, Ayla Stuart Schaefer wrote:
Attached is a draft of the Component Model Test plan. Feedback is appreciated.
Stuart