Folks, As for the roles description, I agree that the proposed definitions contributes to the better understanding of the ACS for those who read the document. Especially Producer and Consumer are what are missed in the previous draft. So I'd like to include them in the chapter 3 Architecture in the specification. My proposal here is to make the description for the Replicator to be a note rather than a separate role. It can be placed as, for example (please brush up my English here if you can): -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Note: The entity that acts as both the consumer and the producer can provide combined feature of those, for example, replicating and recreating an archive for modified use for other task and/or by another client. They can also register the archive to another instance of ACS. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- In my mind, the replicator is a special case for the producer and the consumer. It doesn't act as the central part of the ACS use cases, either. The above fits better to that view and contributes to the better understanding for those who read the specification. Any comments? -Keisuke -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1.1.1 Roles ACS identifies three broad categories of roles of users of the ARI. Note that these roles are used purely for the purposes of describing the ARI. These roles are not explicitly identified or enforced by ARI. The roles are: •Producer – owner of an application that is to be archived into ACS. This role supports create, update, and delete operations on an AA. •Consumer – users of ARI that want to retrieve information about an AA or retrieve portions of an AA. This role only supports Get operations. •Replicator – a special version of Consumer that enables getting a formatted version of the complete AA for the purposes of recreating the AA in another instance of ACS. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------