Tom, Thanks for your comments. Though we will also cover these and many are understandable, I and Sachiko felt difficulty in understanding your comment below: Thomas Studwell wrote:
Chart 4: User provides a collection of information and the AC and ADD for a AA they wish to have created. They do not, as a Producer, generate an AA per se, the exception is a case where the user wishes to create a replica but I call this a Replicator function rather than a Producer function (and very important reason that we agree on and keep the roles distinct). We need to develop the type of information that needs to be included in the collection but it has things like Description, Owner, Access Rights, etc.
Sachiko pointed me that there may be some discrepancy between us on understanding the use cases here. Does your comment above means (3) is your main use case? FYI, I thought the case (1) would be the bottom line one, then (2) will be realized as a more value added form of the service implementations. In my opinion, (3) is questionable because I don't see points here. I understand that Mike and Sachiko is also doubtful about (3)
Slide 4: Agree about #3 not being needed.
We can discuss more at the next session. -Keisuke